The Importance of Civil Reservations in Automobile Accident Cases

18 Mar 2015 Written by  Bryan Mintz
Auto Accident Attorneys Auto Accident Attorneys

This week, in Maida v. Kuskin, the New Jersey Supreme Court addressed an important aspect of civil reservations.

A civil reservation is a request made by a defendant when pleading guilty to a traffic offense that his or her guilty plea not be used in a subsequent civil action.  R. 7:6-2(a)(1) provides that “[o]n the request of the defendant, the court may, at the time of the acceptance of a guilty plea, order that the plea shall not be evidential in any civil proceeding.”

In Maida, the defendant did not request a civil reservation until after the hearing via a post-hearing letter to the Court. New Jersey’s Supreme Court made a clear pronouncement that the Rule requires that any civil reservation made when pleading guilty to a traffic offense must be made in open court and not after the proceedings.

Lawyers for the plaintiffs as well as amicus curiae, New Jersey Association for Justice, argued that a victim’s right to notice of a plea and to object to the issuance of a civil reservation would be frustrated if the request was not made in open court. The New Jersey Supreme Court agreed.

This has important implications in any personal injury case involving an automobile accident in which liability is contested. Without a civil reservation in place, guilty pleas to traffic offenses will be ammunition for plaintiffs’ attorneys because the plea could be considered a party admission in lawsuits and used as evidence of a defendant’s negligence.

This case demonstrates that if you suffered serious injuries in a motor vehicle accident, it is very important to immediately contact a New Jersey attorney who is knowledgeable about the most recent developments in the law.

New Jersey and New York Workers' Compensation and Automobile Accident Attorneys

We give personal attention to all of our clients. If you or a loved one has been injured while at work or in a car accident, call us today at 908-352-2323 or send us an email by clicking here to evaluate your case.

Our workers compensation attorneys and automobile accident lawyers serve clients throughout New Jersey and New York, including the cities of Newark, Elizabeth, Jersey City, Hackensack, and Morris, Bergen, Hudson, Union and Middlesex counties. We have offices in Elizabeth, New Jersey and New York City.

At Mintz & Geftic, WE WILL FIGHT FOR YOU!

Last modified on Friday, 08 January 2016 18:44

Contact Us

qr code

Use QR scan to save on 
your phone and share.

Main Office:
618 Newark Avenue
Elizabeth, NJ 07208

New York Office:
Empire State Building
350 Fifth Ave, 59th Floor
New York, NY 10118