NJ Supreme Court Limits Workers’ Compensation for Cardiovascular Injuries

16 Dec 2014 Written by  jerseylawyer.com
Supreme Court Justice Barry Albin speaks at the New Jersey State Bar Association's annual meeting and convention held in Atlantic City. Friday May 15, 2013 Supreme Court Justice Barry Albin speaks at the New Jersey State Bar Association's annual meeting and convention held in Atlantic City. Friday May 15, 2013 Patti Sapone/The Star-Ledger

The New Jersey Supreme Court decided last week in the case of Renner v. AT&T that a Workers’ Compensation claimant is not entitled to compensation for a cardiovascular injury, disease or death, unless the claimant can show that the cardiovascular injury resulted from a work effort or strain involving a substantial condition or event.  This case has broad ramifications for New Jersey workers who suffer injuries such as heart attacks or pulmonary embolisms at work and seek workers’ compensation benefits for those injuries.

In this case, Cathleen Renner was an employee of AT&T who had a telecommuting agreement with the company.  The agreement allowed Renner to work from her home office.  On the evening of September 24, 2007, Cathleen worked from her home office for several hours, and continued working on a project through the night and into the next morning.  Cathleen did not finish the project until 10:30 a.m.  Approximately one hour later, Cathleen called EMS, who found her face down on the floor screaming that she could not breathe.  EMS workers tried to resuscitate her, but were unsuccessful, and she was pronounced dead when she arrived at the hospital.  The cause of death was a pulmonary embolism.

Cathleen’s doctor, a board certified internal medicine physician, testified that Cathleen’s work effort of sitting at her desk for many hours contributed materially to a deep vein thrombosis and caused her death.  In addition, he noted that the sedentary nature of her work also contributed to her death.   A doctor for AT&T, however, testified that additional lifestyle factors contributed to the embolism, including obesity, birth control pill use, and age.

While the workers’ compensation judge accepted Cathleen’s doctor’s opinion as more probable, the New Jersey State Supreme Court reversed that decision.   According to the Supreme Court, in order for a worker to receive compensation for a cardiovascular injury, the worker must prove by a preponderance of the evidence that in the injury or death was produced by a work effort or strain that is in excess of the “wear and tear” of the claimant’s daily living.  In Cathleen’s case, the Court determined that, while she may have spent much of her time sitting, she was not required to do so by her job, and that she was free to stand, stretch, walk around, and leave her workstation.  Therefore, the prolonged sitting was not compelled by her job and her injury was not compensable.

Elizabeth, New Jersey Workers' Compensation Lawyers

We give personal attention to all of our clients. If you or a loved one has been injured while working, call our New Jersey lawyers today today at 908-352-2323 or send us an email by clicking here to evaluate your case.

Our  workers' compensation lawyers serve clients throughout New Jersey and New York, including the cities of Newark, Elizabeth, Jersey City, Hackensack, and Morris, Bergen, Hudson, Union and Middlesex counties. We have offices in Elizabeth, New Jersey and New York City.

WE WILL FIGHT FOR YOU!

 

 

Last modified on Monday, 11 July 2016 18:32

Contact Us

qr code

Use QR scan to save on 
your phone and share.

Main Office:
618 Newark Avenue
Elizabeth, NJ 07208
908-352-2323
(800-894-2320)

New York Office:
Empire State Building
350 Fifth Ave, 59th Floor
New York, NY 10118
1-800-894-2320